| Name | Vote | Comments |
|---|
| | Y | |
| | Y | |
| | N | Just a comment. There was a substancial amount of damage caused to the trees at the base when this route was 'cleaned', which if find offensive. |
| | Y | This seems like a good line for a new route but I have one suggestion before any bolts are placed. I think the route should be climbed on toprope to confirm that it is "doable" prior to bolting. |
| | Y | |
| | Y | I support the new route, but do not support the convenience anchors (proposed separately) that are being suggested for the start of this climb. |
| | Y | |
| | Y | This looks like a stellar climb,maybe the biggest roof in eldo.please send in one pitch. |
| | Y | |
| | Y | |
| | Y | Wish I could climb that hard, but someone could, so why not. |
| | Y | |
| | Y | I was up there last week and saw the taped X's marking where the bolts would be and I thought it looked like it would be a pretty nice line. |
| | Y | Looks like a cool line! My only hesitation is that in my opinion, since it will be rap-bolted, there should be NO doubt that it does go and it does NOT have major loose holds. The first ascencionist should be able to do it on demand on TR, so there is no question...The other seemingly doable route on Peanuts stayed unredpointed for a while. |
| | Y | Seems like it would be a good line. Sure. Yes. |
| | Y | |
| | Y | |
| | Y | |
| | Y | |
| | Y | Sure- new route, why not. Looks good. If the bolter can't finish it, someone will get it soon. There are plenty of strong folks areound, so by all means, put it in.
But- Please do your best to clean up the noted loose rocks on the traverse section so as not to kill someone later... better to chuck the stuff off under watch than drop a brink on an unsuspecting climber's head in the future. |
| | Y | |
| | Y | Seems reasonable. |
| | Y | |
| | Y | |
| | Y | |
| | Y | Looks fun, noncontrived, and not overbolted. |
| | Y | Sounds like a great addition to the canyon |
| | Y | This would be a good idea. |
| | Y | |
| | Y | Looks like a wild rock climb. |
| | Y | This is a well thought out route that I aspire to climb in the coming years.
|
| | Y | i trust joe to do the right thing |
| | Y | seems like good independent line |
| | Y | |
| | Y | Looks like a great line. |
| | Y | |
| | Y | I helped joe work on this route. I think that it is a worthy addition to the route population in Eldo. |
| | Y | |
| | Y | |
| | Y | I know Joe very well and he has a great reputation for ethics. I support this proposal even without first hand knowledge of the area or climb in question. Joe will create a first rate climb to be enjoyed by all of us. |
| | Y | I am only slightly concerned because the route has not been climbed "but looks doable". However, from my understanding an unclimbed and abandoned project resulting from this appears highs unlikely. TI looks like a good route. |
| | Y | |
| | Y | Looks like a fun route! |
| | Y | Looks like theres a proposed 2 bolt anchor at the start of the route too judging by the big white crosses you can see from the Fowler trail. Are those going in too? |
| | Y | |
| | Y | Similar to Your Mother, but on cleaner stone with a good mix of classic power movement and a technical crux at the finish. |
| | Y | Cool! |
